Ditch Headway, one piece at a time.
Headway has announced a $9.99 fee per client, per session for clients who found you through its marketplace. Not once per referral — every session, for as long as you see them.
Headway does five jobs for you, and every one of them can be done without it. This is the order to replace them in so that nobody misses a session and you never go a month without being paid.
You don’t have to leave all at once, and you shouldn’t. The first step takes 90–150 days and everything else fits inside that wait.
a year in marketplace fees, at $9.99 × 46 worked weeks.
- Psychology Today, a whole year
- $348
- Google Business Profile
- $0
- Your insurer’s own directory
- $0
What the marketplace fee costs you
Count only the clients who came to you through Headway’s directory — the ones the fee applies to.
A referral fee that never stops charging
A directory charges you to be found. This charges you for every hour you spend with someone after they found you, for as long as the work goes on. It turns Headway from a billing service into a landlord on your caseload.
It costs more the longer the work goes on
The fee is per session, so the clients it charges most are the ones you keep longest: trauma work, long-term depression, anyone who needs a year rather than six weeks. A per-session toll quietly rewards short treatment.
It sits on top of a cut you already pay
Headway was never free. Its revenue is the difference between what it negotiates with each insurer and what it pays you, and some insurers have been cutting what platforms receive. This new fee comes on top of that margin.
Flat directories charge far less
Psychology Today is $29 a month whether it sends you one client or ten. A single client seen weekly through Headway’s marketplace now costs more in a year than a year on Psychology Today.
Everything Headway does, and what replaces it
Headway bundles five things. Unbundled, they cost somewhere between nothing and about $100 a month, plus a few hours of setup each.
| What Headway does | What replaces it | Typical cost |
|---|---|---|
| Puts you in-network | Your own contracts with the two or three insurers that cover most of your clients, through a CAQH profile | $0, or $100–300 per payer if you hire it out |
| Notes, calendar and telehealth | An EHR with a signed BAA: SimplePractice, TherapyNotes or Sessions Health | $29–99/mo |
| Claims, eligibility and payouts | Your EHR’s built-in claims and clearinghouse, or a billing service | included, or 4–8% of collections |
| Collecting copays | Card on file in your EHR, or Ivy Pay | ~2.9% + 30¢ |
| The marketplace | Google Business Profile, your insurers’ directories, Psychology Today, one niche directory, and colleagues who refer | $0–60/mo, flat |
Start the slow part today, then build while you wait
Insurance contracts take months and nothing else does. So the applications go in first, everything else gets set up while they’re pending, and your Headway clients move only once there is somewhere in-network for them to move to.
- Week 1CAQH profile done, applications in to two or three insurers.
- Weeks 2–3EHR chosen and BAA signed. Google profile and directory listings live.
- Weeks 4–20Take new clients through your own listings. Stop taking new ones through Headway’s marketplace.
- Contracts landTell clients, sign them onto your own intake, bill the next session yourself.
- Last sessionDownload every record, then close the account. Watch for claim adjustments for a year.
Get in-network on your own
Bills under its own group contracts with insurers, so you’re in-network within weeks without negotiating anything.
Your own contract with each insurer. It takes longer to get and often pays the same or more per session.
- Count your clients by insurer. Your Headway client list shows each client’s plan. The two or three insurers that cover most of your clients are the ones to apply to. Applying to everyone triples the paperwork for little gain.
- Build or refresh your CAQH ProView profile. It’s free, and most commercial insurers read your application from it. Upload your license, malpractice certificate, CV and W-9, then re-attest. An expired attestation is the most common reason applications sit untouched.
- Get a Type 2 NPI if you have an LLC or PLLC. It’s free from NPPES and takes about ten minutes. Bill under the entity if you formed one, and under your individual NPI if you didn’t.
- Apply to each insurer directly through their provider portal, and write down the date and reference number. Follow up every 30 days. Credentialing that nobody chases gets lost.
- If a panel says it’s closed, ask for an exception. Name your specialty, your languages, or a population that’s hard to place locally. Panels are closed by default and open when you give them a reason.
Don’t cancel anything yet. Until a contract is signed and has an effective date, your Headway clients have no in-network route to you. Leave too early and they either pay out of network or stop coming.
Move your notes, calendar and telehealth
Gives you somewhere to keep notes, schedule sessions and run video calls, at no charge, inside its platform.
An EHR you own the account for and can export from. It will hold years of your notes, so choose it as if you can’t switch.
- Pick an EHR that does insurance claims if any of your income comes from insurance. Check the tier, too: SimplePractice’s cheapest plan doesn’t bill insurers.
- Sign the BAA before you enter anything. Every serious EHR offers one. If a tool won’t sign one, don’t use it.
- Download every record from Headway: intake forms, treatment plans, progress notes and assessments, for every client, current and past. Your state requires you to keep records for years after discharge, and that duty stays with you, not with the platform.
- Rebuild your paperwork once: informed consent, a no-show policy, a telehealth consent and a release of information. Your EHR has templates to start from.
Take over claims, eligibility and getting paid
Checks each client’s benefits, submits the claim, chases denials, and pays you on a schedule whenever the insurer gets around to paying.
Your EHR’s claims tools, or a billing service. You get paid when the insurer pays, which is usually two to four weeks after a clean claim.
- Enroll in electronic payments with each insurer (EFT for the deposits, ERA for the remittances) through your EHR’s clearinghouse. Skip this and you’ll get paper checks.
- Check benefits before the first session you bill yourself, not after. A client’s copay, deductible and any authorization requirement can differ from what they had through Headway’s contract.
- Keep a month of expenses in the business account. The first direct payments arrive weeks after the first sessions, so you’ll have a gap with no income.
- Block 30 minutes a week for claims: denials, resubmissions, and checking that what arrived matches what you expected. Most lost money comes from denials that never get resubmitted.
Collect copays and cash-pay sessions
Keeps the client’s card on file and charges the copay automatically.
Card on file in your EHR, charged automatically when a session is marked complete.
- Turn on card processing inside the EHR rather than adding a separate processor. That way each charge is tied to its session and there’s nothing to reconcile.
- Get a card on file at intake, and write your late-cancellation fee into the consent the client signs.
- Offer superbills to clients whose insurer you didn’t credential with, so they can claim out-of-network benefits themselves.
Replace the marketplace with places that charge a flat fee, or nothing
Lists you in a search where clients filter by insurance, and now charges $9.99 for every session with every client who found you there.
Four or five listings that charge a flat monthly fee or nothing, and none that charge per session.
The marketplace’s real advantage is that clients search by insurance and see what they’ll pay. Once you have your own contracts, you get that advantage free: insurers have to list you in their own directories, and Psychology Today lets clients filter by insurance too.
- Write one profile and reuse it everywhere. About 150 words, starting with the problem in the client’s own words (“I can’t get on a plane”) before your methods. Then who you work with, what a first session looks like, which insurance you take, and how to book.
- Claim your Google Business Profile. It’s free, it often ranks above every therapy directory for “therapist near me”, and it starts showing up within days of verification. A telehealth-only practice can still list a service area.
- Check your listing in each insurer’s directory as each contract goes live. The No Surprises Act requires insurers to keep their directories accurate and asks you to confirm your details at least every 90 days, so put that on your calendar. Clients searching their insurer’s directory are already insured and know their costs, which is the same audience Headway’s marketplace had, and you pay nothing for it.
- List on Psychology Today and fill in the insurance section. It’s still the largest source of therapy enquiries, at $29 a month however many clients it sends.
- Add one niche directory that fits how you work, rather than five general ones.
- Tell five people who refer. A primary care practice, a psychiatrist, a school counselor and two colleagues who are full. These referrals are free and the best fit you’ll get, and they’re where established practices get most of their clients.
- Answer every enquiry within a day. Most directories rank fast responders higher, and someone looking for a therapist usually books with whoever answers first.
The full list, with what each one is good for, is in the directories row of the plan. Stop taking new clients through Headway’s marketplace now. Every new client you take there adds to the fee for as long as they stay.
Move your clients without dropping anyone
This is the step to go slowly on. Changing platforms should change nothing about the therapy except the paperwork.
Read your Headway provider agreement first. Look for anything about non-solicitation, transferring clients or notice periods before you raise this with a single client. If something is unclear, an hour with a healthcare attorney costs less than a dispute.
- Sort your caseload into three groups. Clients whose insurer you’re now contracted with directly. Clients whose insurer you aren’t. Clients close to finishing.
- Insurer you’re contracted with: tell the client in session, not in an email, and give at least 30 days’ notice. Their copay should stay about the same. They sign your intake and consent in your EHR, and you bill the next session yourself after checking their benefits.
- Insurer you aren’t contracted with: offer out-of-network care with a superbill, a sliding-scale rate, or staying on Headway until they finish, if your agreement allows it. If none of those work for them, make a warm referral rather than a list of names.
- Close to finishing: let them finish where they are. A few months of fees costs less than disrupting treatment that’s nearly done.
- Write a note in each chart recording that you discussed the change, what you offered, and what the client chose.
Close the account properly
- Download your records again, after the last session has been billed. The first export won’t include anything written since.
- Keep the last year of Headway payment statements. Insurers can take back payments for sessions months after paying them, and you’ll need the statements to check any recoupment.
- Update CAQH and every directory so nothing still points clients to your Headway profile.
- Close the account in writing, giving whatever notice your agreement requires, and keep a copy.
What you give up
Leaving isn’t free either, and it’s better to know the costs before you start.
A few months of waiting
Getting contracted takes 90–150 days per insurer, and some panels near you will be closed. That’s the reason step one comes first.
The paperwork comes back to you
Denials, re-credentialing, benefit checks. Budget 30 minutes a week, or pay a billing service a percentage of what you collect.
Slower payment
Insurers pay on their own schedule, not Headway’s. Keep a month of expenses in the business account to cover the gap.
The rate may not go up
Published comparisons put Headway’s rates close to direct contracts on average, but it varies by state and insurer. Ask each insurer for its fee schedule before you sign, and compare it with your Headway rate.
Then build the rest of the practice.
The plan walks through the other decisions that come with going independent, including the entity, malpractice cover, the money side, CE hours and renewals, with prices and a calendar built from what you pick. It’s free, it runs in your browser, and nothing you enter is sent anywhere.
Open the plan